Renew On Line (UK) number 72

Extracts from NATTA's journal
Renew, Issue 172 Mar/Apr2008
   Welcome   Archives   Bulletin         


1. Big UK wind push

2. Zero Carbon Buildings

3. Nuclear Decision

4. Energy Policy developments

5. Tory Green Energy Promises

6. Brown on Energy...and Climate

7. Biofuels and biomass get going

8. EU News: REFIT spreads

9. Global News: Climate High, Bali Low

10. World Round up: Oz, NZ, Canada try

11. Nuclear news: US and UK plans

4. Energy Policy developments
EU Renewables Directive

UK gets off lightly
The legally binding target proposed by the EU for the UK as its contribution to helping the EU as a whole to get 20% of its energy from renewables by 2020, has been set at 15%. Most other countries didn’t get off so lightly: Portugal’s target was 31%, Denmark’s 30%, France got 23%, Spain 20%, Germany 18%, Greece 18%, Italy 17%, and Ireland 16%. The big hitters were Austria at 34%, Finland at 38%, Sweden 49%- and Latvia at 42%. Some other ex-Soviet countries also had highish targets: Slovenia 25%, Estonia 25%. Lithuania 23%, and Romania 24%.

Countries who can’t meet their targets can buy in green energy credits from those with excess, under a new voluntary ‘guarantee of origin’ system, and they can ‘burden share’ with projects both in and outside of the EU Emission Trading System. They can also top up with credits from outside the EU. These proposals will now be debated- and finalised by early next year. There’s plenty to discuss- e.g. REFIT seems safe, but what are the sanctions if the targets aren’t met? More in Renew 173.
* DBERR’s John Hutton is chairing an enhanced Renewable Advisory Board with a wider remit to advise the Government on how to meet the UK’s target under this new EU Directive. 15% is still very challenging- we are at about 2% at present.
Scotland splashes out
Scotland’s first SNP Budget & Spending Review included a commitment to create a new Sustainable Development and Climate Change fund of over £30m and to treble support for the Scottish Community & Householder Renewables Initiative to £13.5m each year.
There is also to be an annual £2m prize to encourage innovation in renewable generation, and a £10m Horizon Prize ‘to attract the cream of the world’s scientists to put Scotland firmly on the international map as a leading centre for renewable energy solutions’. 20% of Scottish electricity demand is now met by renewables and the Spending Review set a target of getting to 31% by 2011. Ministers have also set a target of getting 50% of electricity from renewables by 2020, up from the previous aim of having 40% by 2020. But not all is full ahead: maybe wisely they have decided against the giant Lewis wind farm..

Energy Bill 
The new Energy Bill, mentioned in the Queens Speech last Nov., and launched in parallel with the Nuclear White Paper, tidies up various elements of UK energy policy in line with the last years Energy White Paper. Some of it sounds fine. It aims to ‘provide greater incentives for renewable energy generation’ and to ‘strengthen the Renewables Obligation to drive greater and more rapid deployment of renewables in the UK’. That includes the proposed RO technology banding arrangements. Maybe neutral are the proposals ‘to make it easier for private firms to invest in offshore gas supply infrastructure’ and to ‘strengthen the market framework to help ensure secure and affordable energy supplies and encourage a diverse, secure supply of electricity’, assuming that is you like market mechanisms. In addition it introduces ‘a regulatory framework to enable private sector investment in carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects’. And finally there are measures ‘to ensure owners of new nuclear power stations pay their share of decommissioning and waste costs’.

Planning Reform Bill
The new Planning Reform Bill proposes an Independent Infrastructure Planning Commission to oversee major projects and speed up the planning process. The draft of the Bill attracted plenty of objections to what was seen as a dangerous centralisation, and in response, the new version seems likely to stress the role of consultation. The government says that the Bill ‘intends to produce more timely and predictable decisions on infrastructure projects which are important for economic growth, energy security, climate change and other key issues. More decisions will be devolved to local authorities, and there will be a more efficient appeals process.’ It addition ‘It will require developers of major projects to consult affected people and communities before submitting planning applications’
Reactions to that were still pretty negative. e.g., the Green Party said that ‘The current proposals for a separate planning system for major infrastructure projects mean undermining democracy in favour of an increasingly centralised and authoritarian government’.
PRASEG told ‘no to Green Certificates, yes to REFIT’

One of the main architects of Germany’s renewables policy, Hans-Josef Fell, recently met with UK MPs to shore up support for EU renewable targets and the REFIT system and to resist the EC’s plans, evidently backed by the UK government, for a shift to Mandatory Trading of green energy certificates (see Renew 171). At a meeting in the Commons, Fell told the all party Parliamentary Renewables and Sustainable Energy Group that ‘The discussion in the EU Commission to promote renewables in the EU with a certificate system called ‘mandatory trade’ could in fact hinder the growth of renewables, instead of increasing them. The example of unsuccessful political framework in some countries shows this clearly.’ And he added ‘instead of trying to lobby for support from France and Poland for its latest EU proposals, the UK could rule the waves again by unleashing its abundant tidal wave and offshore wind energy potential’.
In the event, the EC came up with proposals for a voluntary system for trading excess ‘Guarantees of Origin’ certificates, which could be less harmful. The debate continues.
Meanwhile see:

Action in the Cities
Bristol, Leeds and Manchester are developing action plans to cut their CO2 emissions. Under a new Low Carbon Cities Programme, the Carbon Trust & the Energy Saving Trust will work to develop individual city-wide action plans to achieve low carbon economies which are both prosperous & sustainable. New measures & initiatives will be introduced and could include renewable energy and trigeneration (creating power, heat and cooling from a single source) along with energy saving measures such as insulation and promoting cycling to work. £250,000 from Defra will also benefit the other members of the Core Cities Group, Sheffield, Birmingham, Liverpool, Newcastle, and Nottingham, by producing audits of emissions and identifying cost effective carbon saving options.
* Over 50 applications to be eco-towns- the first newtowns for nearly half a century- have been received from across the country. DEFRA says that all homes will be built to higher environmental standards, and to zero carbon from 2016, with a million zero carbon homes in the decade after. The Prime Minister announced a coalition of 170 organisations- homebuilders, councils, planners and green groups- who have now signed up to this goal. 78 extra Local Authorities, the majority of which are in the three Northern regions, have also now applied to become new growth points in response to the Housing Green Paper, with the potential to deliver 450,000 extra homes.
Meanwhile Bristol has become one of the latest ‘Transition Towns’. See:

Energy Conservation
Asked on 29th Oct about supporting local campaigns to save electricity as part of its strategy on tackling climate change, a DEFRA Minister noted that: ‘The Government are working at a regional and community level through the Climate Change Communications Initiative which has provided £8.5m to 83 local projects to help raise awareness of climate change, encourage positive attitudes and provide advice on action to help tackle it. My department also funds the Energy Saving Trust. The ESTs Community Partnerships programme works with and provides advice & support to local bodies, to help them deliver energy efficiency to their communities. The Community Energy Efficiency Fund (CEEF), which is funded by my department, aims to ensure 300,000 of the most vulnerable pensioner and other vulnerable households are assisted using an area based approach. In Sept. 2007, 50 projects totalling £6.3m were offered funding by CEEF, including a range of new and established projects, each bringing together key players at the local level to improve the effectiveness of Warm Front and Energy Efficiency Commitment.’

Life cycle emissions from Biofuels
A parliamentary question in Oct last year on greenhouse gas emissions from biofuels, elicited the response that ‘carbon savings can vary widely, depending on how much fossil energy is used in cultivation, harvesting, processing and transportation. For example, the Government-sponsored Low Carbon Vehicle Partnership has calculated that the carbon savings for UK wheat-based ethanol compared to petrol can vary from 7 % to 77%. For this reason, the forthcoming renewable transport fuel obligation (RTFO) will require companies to measure and report on how much carbon their fuel has saved over the entire lifecycle from grain to tank. From 2010, when experience with carbon measurement and reporting has been established, the Government have announced their intention that the RTFO will reward fuels according to their carbon savings.’

Marine Bill
DEFRA say that the proposals for environmental protection in the draft Marine Planning Bill got widespread support, and there is certainly support for more to be done. The Commons Science and Technology Select Committee said funding for marine science and technology had fallen in real terms in the last decade and insisted that the oceans must be ‘explored, monitored, studied and understood more thoroughly than has been the case up to now’ because of their importance to climate, biodiversity, renewable energy resources, food supply and other services. The committee called for the creation of a new marine agency to co-ordinate marine science and ocean monitoring. A new draft of the Bill is due.
It’s odd that the UK, as an Island nation, with a long maritime history, and now a huge offshore engineering industry as well as a growing offshore wind, wave and tidal industry, doesn’t have a Minister responsible for offshore industry & environment.
Marine renewables 'slow', says RAB
The Renewables Advisory Board has produced a grim report on wave and tidal current power- progress is slower than expected, with as yet no projects able to avail themselves of grants from the governments £42m fund for wave and tidal current projects. Evidently the funding scheme is fine, it's the technologies that aren't yet up to it! . More in Renew 173
80% CO2 cut OK….
The UK can cut its CO2 emissions by 80% by 2050 without much economic damage, according to a report by the Institute for Public Policy Research, WWF and the RSPB. It would cut GDP growth by 2-3% but the economy would still triple in size- though 2 years later than it would otherwise.
… UK Climate doubts
A study led by Dietr Helm at Oxford University claims that UK emissions, with air travel, shipping and imports included, have acually increased by 19% since 1990, not reduced by 15% as claimed.

OFGEM good
Energy regulator Ofgem’s second annual Sustainable Development Report, says it was making good progress encouraging the sustainable energy industry, and its chair said it ‘could make a significant contribution to the government’s objectives on sustainability with our current remit and within the framework of competitive energy markets and independent regulation’. Earlier, the Sustainable Development Commission had called for major remit changes.
All’s well..
DBERR’s new ‘Energy Markets Outlook’ is worth a look: though it adopts a fairly complacent view of short-term fossil fuel constraints (no mention of peak oil), it’s pretty optimistic about the long term prospects for renewables. But its blind spot on the oil issue is odd: DBERR says UK energy security is fine for now:
But is it? See:

NATTA/Renew Subscription Details

Renew is the bi-monthly 30 plus page newsletter of NATTA, the Network for Alternative Technology and Technology Assessment. NATTA members gets Renew free. NATTA membership cost 18 pa (waged) 12pa (unwaged), 6 pa airmail supplement (Please make cheques payable to 'The Open University', NOT to 'NATTA')

Details from NATTA , c/o EERU,
The Open University,
Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA
Tel: 01908 65 4638 (24 hrs)

The full 32 (plus) page journal can be obtained on subscription
The extracts here only represent about 25% of it.

This material can be freely used as long as it is not for commercial purposes and full credit is given to its source.

The views expressed should not be taken to necessarily reflect the views of all NATTA members, EERU or the Open University.

We are now offering to e-mail subscribers a PDF version of the complete Renew, instead  of sending them the printed version, should they wish.