Renew On Line (UK) number 72

Extracts from NATTA's journal
Renew, Issue 172 Mar/Apr2008
   Welcome   Archives   Bulletin         


1. Big UK wind push

2. Zero Carbon Buildings

3. Nuclear Decision

4. Energy Policy developments

5. Tory Green Energy Promises

6. Brown on Energy...and Climate

7. Biofuels and biomass get going

8. EU News: REFIT spreads

9. Global News: Climate High, Bali Low

10. World Round up: Oz, NZ, Canada try

11. Nuclear news: US and UK plans

8. EU News
EU- ETS: Euro 20bn windfall

Under Phase I of the EU’s Emissions Trading Scheme which ran up to 2007, industries, including power generators, were allocated free permits to emit carbon and were allowed to sell any surplus over and above what they need to meet the emission cap imposed on them under the EU-ETS rules, to those who exceeded their ceilings. Michael Grubb, Chief Economist at the Carbon Trust has calculated that this practice gave the industry windfall profits of € 20 bn p.a.
Unsurprisingly this raised eyebrows, especially since companies can also pass the extra costs of meeting the caps on to consumers. There have been pressures to switch to an auction of carbon permits, rather than a free handout. And Under Phase II (2008-12), ceilings are being reduced (see Renew 171) and it seems a small percentage will be auctioned, although, according the Reuters ‘the vast majority will still be handed out free’. Reuters reported that ‘News of the vast windfall profits has generated controversy in the Netherlands and Germany but raised barely a ripple in Britain where consumers have been repeatedly told their rising energy bills are due to supply problems- notably from Russia’. It may have helped win acceptance of the scheme from companies. But it can’t go on like this, as even the companies now seem to recognise. Reuters noted that E.ON ‘has after a boardroom battle come out in favour of 100% auction of emission allowances after 2012,’ and the EC’s new proposals for phase III (2013-20) include a shift to auctioning around 60%. More on the EC’s complex new plan in Renew 173.
* E3 International claims that around 18m ETS phase1 credits were double counted!

Germany: 40%emission cut
The German cabinet has approved an environment Ministry plan to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 40% by the year 2020. ‘All economical and social sectors will contribute’ environment minister Siegmar Gabriel promised. ‘We have enough options and tools- but we must also apply them with determination and we must do so quickly’ says the new study “Climate protection in Germany: 40% reduction of CO2 emissions by 2020 compared to 1990” published recently by the German Federal Environment Agency.
The 30-point plan will require changes to several laws which could take up to a year to achieve and so may only take effect under the next government, due to be elected in late 2009. Consumers are expected to play their part with most of energy savings coming from public and private buildings, households and transport. From 2008, funding for climate change activities is to be increased from an annual € 700m to € 2.6bn. This represents an approximately 200% increase in funding on 2005. The share of renewable energy sources in electricity production will rise from today’s 13% to 25-30% by 2030. Also, the share of electricity generated using combined heat and power will increase by 25% by 2020, with an annual € 750m being allocated. A switch to renewables-generated heat will be prescribed by law. In future, 15% of energy used for heating in new buildings will have to come from renewable energy sources. The requirement will also apply to existing buildings when they are completely remodernised. According to Gabriel, greater use of renewables can double the number of jobs in the sector. Some 214,000 people currently work in the sector. The German edition of the Financial Times called Merkel, a conservative, ‘Germany’s greenest head of government to date’. Economics Minister Michael Glos said ‘We aim to be the worlds most energy-efficient country’.
* Nearly 23GW of offshore wind is to be installed along the N.German coast by 2020
Sources: Greenprices, Reuters, Windpower Monthly,

Wind helps EU meet target
The European Commission says the EU will almost meet it target of obtaining 21% of its electricity from renewables by 2010- it’s projecting that 19% of EU gross domestic electricity will come from renewables by 2010 at current rates of progress. This success has been aided by the record 7.5GW of wind capacity built in Europe in 2006: wind now supplies 3.3% of EU electricity. It’s estimated that by 2020 wind capacity will rise from its current EU level of 50GW, producing 100TWh, to 180 GW, producing 500 TWh by 2020, and some studies say it could supply 16% of EU electricity.
Germany remains in the lead with 21,283 MW. It should be able to meet the new EU target of obtaining 20% of energy from renewables by 2020- in fact it’s aiming for 30%. But the UK, and some others will find it very hard on current plans. Source:

REFIT spreads
Renewable Energy Feed-In Tariffs are spreading around the EU, as the map show, with Finland now set to join in.
Mauri Pekkarinen, Finnish trade & industry minister, has proposed that Finland should introduce a feed-in tariff programme to promote the adoption of renewables. He said that market-based measures were not enough to meet the EU’s renewable energy targets. According to the trade and industry ministry, Finland should quadruple the use of thinning and felling waste and raise wind power capacity 20-fold to reach the goals.
* See the Technology section of Renew 172 for more on how the REFIT system works in Germany where it was pioneered- and the problems with the UK’s Renewables Obligation. Our Reviews section looks at a study of how the UK could benefit from REFIT.

Solar FIT for Italy
Last year, Italy approved new incentives to boost PV- photo voltaic solar. It’s adopted a REFIT system and ordered all new buildings to have PV panels on roofs to exploit its abundant sunshine- about 30% more per sq metre than in Germany, the PV leader. Italy has amended its solar law to align it with a German-style feed-in tariff, with guaranteed above-market prices for PV. As a result it hopes to boost installed PV capacity to 3GW by 2016- that’s what Germany has already.
Under the revised Italian law, PV system operators would get up to € 0.49/ kWh for 20 years, so that operators and individuals can repay investments within 8 to 12 years- faster than the 12-16 years in Germany- and get attractive earnings over the entire operations period, The amended Italian law also scraps limits on annual incentives to install PV modules and boosts subsidies for households to put solar panels on roofs.
*Italy’s power utility Enel says it will invest € 300m over 3 years to install over 35 MW of PV. But it’s also keen on nuclear.

French EJP
The French power utility EDF has a price-based demand mangement system, which cuts in when demand peaks. During the peak tariff period ‘Effacement Jour de Pointe’ (EJP), the energy price is at least four times as high as for the usual winter period. There are maximum of 16 EJP days per year, notified a day ahead on the TV, internet etc.

Hungary REEEPs Hungary has became a partner in the Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Partnership (REEEP). It’s the 35th country and the 2nd in Eastern Europe to join. It aims to get 14-16% of it energy from renewables by 2020.

NATTA/Renew Subscription Details

Renew is the bi-monthly 30 plus page newsletter of NATTA, the Network for Alternative Technology and Technology Assessment. NATTA members gets Renew free. NATTA membership cost 18 pa (waged) 12pa (unwaged), 6 pa airmail supplement (Please make cheques payable to 'The Open University', NOT to 'NATTA')

Details from NATTA , c/o EERU,
The Open University,
Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA
Tel: 01908 65 4638 (24 hrs)

The full 32 (plus) page journal can be obtained on subscription
The extracts here only represent about 25% of it.

This material can be freely used as long as it is not for commercial purposes and full credit is given to its source.

The views expressed should not be taken to necessarily reflect the views of all NATTA members, EERU or the Open University.

We are now offering to e-mail subscribers a PDF version of the complete Renew, instead  of sending them the printed version, should they wish.